Letter (10th Jan) by Dr.Adarsh
Dear All,
Thanks for your valuable comments. In the meantime, one request to provide the annexure as mentioned, with citing the reasons, has been sent to MCI. I am attaching herewith the copy of letter sent to MCI for your kind perusal. I request all of you to press for the same, which will give the opportunity to express views by all specialties, as well as the time, so that RTI can be used in an effective manner; buying time is of essence, only by which this document will come to the knowledge of everyone. Still maximum number of faculties of concerned subjects are unaware about this document and that seems to be the hidden agenda of MCI.
Please circulate it to all concerned faculties, surgery, gynae, patho, micro, etc., as they are also equally uncomfortable with this document; only we have to make them aware.
The letter, sent to MCI, is available in the later part of this article.
Thanks for your valuable comments. In the meantime, one request to provide the annexure as mentioned, with citing the reasons, has been sent to MCI. I am attaching herewith the copy of letter sent to MCI for your kind perusal. I request all of you to press for the same, which will give the opportunity to express views by all specialties, as well as the time, so that RTI can be used in an effective manner; buying time is of essence, only by which this document will come to the knowledge of everyone. Still maximum number of faculties of concerned subjects are unaware about this document and that seems to be the hidden agenda of MCI.
Please circulate it to all concerned faculties, surgery, gynae, patho, micro, etc., as they are also equally uncomfortable with this document; only we have to make them aware.
The letter, sent to MCI, is available in the later part of this article.
A Pathologist's view
Dear Forensic Faculty,
I will have to agree 'in principle' regarding the comments expressed by all of you; the vision 2015 seems to be biased, inconvenient, illogical and unwarranted; i add to your views that such proposals are fit to be disposed off into the archives, without implementation.
I will have to agree 'in principle' regarding the comments expressed by all of you; the vision 2015 seems to be biased, inconvenient, illogical and unwarranted; i add to your views that such proposals are fit to be disposed off into the archives, without implementation.
Comments by Dr.Akash Deep Aggarwal
| please visit the two links below to understand the concept of doctors available in india as per GoI data and how it nullifies the basis of the vision-2015 |
In reply to Dr.Shaikh Khaja's Comments
My views to Prof.Shaikh Khaja's letter to MCI (available in this blog).
Comments by Prof. Rema Jagadish
This is to express my apprehension in sidelining Forensic Medicine, in the proposed new curriculum.
Comments by Dr.Zachariah Thomas
The undergraduate education working group has proposed to emasculate and there by going to administer
Are we short of doctors in India?
ANSWER—The MCI has been spreading false scare in order to push up its case
Tips for drafting a letter and e-mailing it.
My personal recommendations about how to draft a letter to MCI and how to e-mail it.
Comments by Dr.Balaram
I came to know of the report submitted by a committe for the rearrangement of medical
Comments by Dr.Uday Singh
Vision 2015 of MCI seems to bring unrealistic vision. The proposed UG curriculaum and the degrading of Forensic Medicine as a subject is unwarrented and is not compatible with our system.
Comments by Dr.Sreekumari & her colleagues
The knowledge of the criminal justice system and its workings is an absolute necessity in the curriculum
Former CJI, Sri Venkatachalaiah's report
Dr Adarsh Kumar, Dr Mahabalesh Shetty, Dr. Badkur, etc., can use the Venkatachaliah Report as the recommended document on highlighting the importance of forensic medicine & toxicology to the MCI BOG.
Letter to MCI by Dr.Shaikh Khaja, Ex-Principal
Most important inputs to develop a vision & fix targets are facts and correct information. It is unfortunate that vision 2015 is flawed at the basic stage itself because
Conducting and Teaching Sexual assault examination by OBG doctors. Is it the right approach?
I would like to enlighten the learned policy makers of the vision-2015.....
Comments by a Principal (Prof.K.W.D.Ravi Chandar)
Dear fellow members representing IAFM, SIMLA & KAMLS at the MCI regarding the proposed document “Vision 2015”
Excerpts of Dr Adarsh's letter
........We have to act very fast and put everything into action in a methodical manner..........While commenting try to be precise and penetrative.............. subject in 2nd or in final year? .........also please comment upon the weightage to be given to toxicology.............distribution of teaching hours need be clarified considering other disciplines ................
Letter to MCI by the President, Indian Society of Toxicology
Letter has been sent to the Chairperson and all members of the MCI BOG on behalf of the Indian Society of Toxicology..............
Excerpts from a letter by young faculty of FM
I request the BOG-MCI to conduct survey before taking decision...
Dr.S.C.Mestri's comments
I request the Forensic medicine & toxicology associations to add to my views and send a draft to MCI on or before 15-01-2011 lest we may have to fight again against their irrational, impractical decision likely to arrive in 2011. The need of hour is swift, stubborn and robust resistance.
Dr.Arun's comments
.......One can hardly do justice (both students as well as teachers) with the reduced frame of time. There is no representation from 2nd year subject experts in the working group. The subjects of Pathology, pharmacology, forensic medicine and microbiology, do serve as strong base for the better comprehension of clinical subjects and hence assigning 1 and a half year to these subjects shall not be considered as a wastage of time......
The medical faculty also reserves its right to know the basis for grouping the medical subjects as A, B and C.
The medical faculty also reserves its right to know the basis for grouping the medical subjects as A, B and C.
Dr.Nagesh's comments
It is not clear whether they want to keep Forensic faculty in UG teaching? If forensic subject is taught by other specialties like OBG, Surgery, etc., what is work for Forensic Specialist? Where is the question of employing a Forensic Specialist in Medical Colleges (especially private medical colleges)? Are they meant for only conducting medicolegal autopsies? If so, how many private medical colleges are conducting medicolegal autopsies?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)